How to Follow Up on a Residency Letter of Recommendation

How to Follow Up on a Residency Letter of Recommendation

Table of Contents

Introduction

You met with your attending, and they agreed to write your letter. Sent the Letter Request Form. You have checked MyERAS four times since lunch. 

Confirmed for upload, but still “Confirmed for Upload.” Not “Uploaded.”

Now, here’s what no one really prepares for: Your attending is not responsible for tracking that letter. It’s yours. In a single sentence, the AAMC’s own guidelines for ERAS say it. The applicant is responsible for following up with the letter authors.

That sentence is not to be taken lightly. In the NRMP’s 2024 Program Director Survey, 84 percent of program directors indicated that letters of recommendation for each specialty are taken into account for who gets invited for an interview, with an average rating of 4.2 on a 1 to 5 scale. On the day a program director opens a file that doesn’t exist, there’s a thinner file.

For an International Medical Graduate (IMG), it hurts more. Your US letters are usually from 4 week USCE rotations, your letter writer could be 8 time zones away and no dean’s office is running after you.

So what you really have to do is know where each letter is, poke at the right time with the right words and be prepared in advance if it is needed. This step by step guide on how to follow up on a letter of recommendation for residency includes emails to copy tonight.

When you log in to your AAMC Portal, you should see the following text: “Read Your AAMC Portal Status Correctly”

Many applicants panic because they misunderstand their portal status. that their attending hasn’t uploaded is the result of a misread status.

All LOR submissions to MyERAS will have one of four statuses. Below are the definitions of each and what you’ll do about it.

MyERAS statusThis is what the MyERAS status means:Your move:
Not Confirmed for UploadYou have created an entry but it is not confirmed. There is no Letter ID available at this time.Verify it (you will need your MyERAS password), and then submit the Letter Request Form. Everything won’t be uploaded until your writer does.
Confirmed for UploadForm is ready and ID has been added. Your writer has not uploaded.This is the “follow up” area. All of the following applies to this.
Uploaded by Your Writer / DesigneeYour writer or their designee uploaded the PDF in the AAMC Letter Writer Portal.Assign to programs. You must assign to get anything to a program director.
ImportedThe letter was carried over from the previous ERAS season.Be sure the specialty fits before assigning it.

“Uploaded” is not the same as “assignment” and only uploaded letters can be assigned, up to 4 per program.

Here are three portal facts that will impact your follow up:

  • AAMC sends you an email message as soon as a letter is uploaded, to your address listed in your Personal Information section. Before checking attending, check spam.
  • There is a Letter ID for each individual letter request. Don’t share the same Letter Request Form with several writers, as each request is for a separate letter.
  • ECFMG’s guidelines for letter writers allow program directors to view the upload time and who uploaded the letter. A letter uploaded on October 30 is like a letter uploaded on October 30. Not deadly but visible.

The Most Important Requirement Before Letter Upload 

The letter can only be uploaded if you waived your right to view it (and for most letters you should), by your writer or the writer’s designee. It can be neither stepped into nor uploaded by ECFMG.

So there’s one thing left: letters that communicate. The remaining points of this article are dedicated to doing it well.

How to Follow Up on a Residency Letter of Recommendation 

It’s not the question “Should we email again?”. The correct answer is ‘what date did we agree on?’

If you have not agreed on a date, that should be your first priority. All asks must have a target date for upload, rather than “when you have the time”.

Here is the follow-up schedule I recommend. that I use for each applicant (and for the agreed upon target date):

WhenWhat you doWhat it signals
At the askNegotiate an agreement on a target date. Submit the Letter Request Form, CV, draft of your personal statement, and a three line summary of what you did during the rotation.A person who is well coordinated and helpful.
2 to 3 weeks prior to the target dateFirst LOR reminder email: brief, courteous, form reattached, include LOR ID and portal link.The vast majority of letters are written in this window.
Target date +3 business daysSecond follow up: direct, offers assistance, requests a response, yes or no.Still completely normal
Target + 10 to 14 days, silenceThird contact via other communication (coordinator, face to face, phone). Turn on the backup writer on the same day.It is not a time for panic, but rather a time for decision making.

Two or three touches for approximately a month, they were getting a bit closer with each one. That’s it!

The 2027 ERAS season falls somewhere in the middle of the residency application timeline, with September 2, 2026, being the start of applications and September 23, 2026, the start of reviews. The season for ERAS is May 31, 2027, but there is no letter submission deadline. The deadline of interest is the respective program’s, many programs cease to review new files well before winter. Verify on each program’s website.

If you are reading this during the middle of the season and have a letter left to submit you are not guaranteed that the programs will consider the letter after your initial application. Late is better than never, particularly when reviewing in waves. Naming your letters prior to sending your application allows programs the opportunity to have them from the start of their review. But no letter will be assured to be read and programs may not read letters after the initial application review.

Weak vs Better: naming the date

Weak: “No hurry, when you have time”.

Better: “I’m submitting on September 2 and would love to have your letter in by August 20. Does that work with your schedule?”

An agreed deadline is not the same as asking your attending to upload the letter whenever they have time. A date is typed into one of them.

Chasing letters while building your whole application?

We help IMGs map rotations, research and mentors to the letters each specialty wants, and keep every one on track to September 23.

Build My ERAS Application →

How to Politely Follow Up With an Attending: First Email (LOR)

The first reminder’s only point is that you’ll make uploading take five minutes.

When making the first reminder email, you should do the following:

  • The subject line identifies you, the task and the date. Nothing cute.
  • No more than three short paragraphs.
  • Re introduce yourself in one line: rotation, service, dates. A year around, dozens of trainees are supervised by the attendings.
  • Attach a PDF Letter ID, portal link, target date, and Letter Request Form.
  • Offer help. Don’t apply pressure.

Deliver it in the middle of the day on Tuesdays through Thursdays in their time zone. Emails get lost Monday emails, and over the weekend forgotten emails Friday.

Subject line of your email:

To: Your Name, Your Rotation, target [date]

To Dr. [Last Name]:

Many thanks for agreeing to write my letter of recommendation for [specialty] residency. I have served with you on [service] from [dates] and will be applying for ERAS on [date].

The ERAS Letter Request Form has been attached to help make the upload easy. The Letter ID will be [ID] and the letter will be uploaded as a PDF via the AAMC Letter Writer Portal (link on the form). If the possibility is there to have it in by [target date] that gives me time to assign it before I submit.

I am willing to send a summary of cases if it would be helpful.

With thanks,

Your name, degree, graduation year | AAMC ID number | phone number

The case summary is not some kind of filler for politeness. A writer who slows down is a writer who is not remembering details, a blank page is more weighty than a busy clinic.

Weak = Better. Weak = Better, opening line.

Weak: “Did you get a chance to look at my letter?”

Better: “I’ve sent an email on [date] and wanted to re send the Letter Request Form, so it’s at the top of your inbox.”

The first message puts pressure on the writer to explain the delay. The second gives him a tool.

A reminder email will not save a letter that was never meant to be a strong letter!

How you chase is dependent on who you ask. We review your rotation history, which writers to seek out and which writers to drop and when each ask fits into the ERAS application timeline for IMGs.

How to Send a Second LOR Follow-Up Email 

Your deadline has expired. Another 3 business days passed and there was still nothing.

This is a common occurrence for good applicants every cycle. Most people either win the letter or lose the relationship in the second LOR follow up email, and it depends on tone.

Part 2 of the rules:

  • Wait three business days after the target, NOT three hours.
  • Please reply in the same thread, the form and Letter ID will be right at your fingertips!
  • Going the extra mile: tie new ask to a real event: “programs begin reviewing on September 23.”
  • Provide them with an escape. Some writers get silent because they feel they no longer have the strength to write a good letter and they don’t know how to say it.
  • Reduce the amount of guilt words used: “just checking”, “following up again”, “haven’t heard back”.

Residency LOR follow up email template (second follow up):

From: Eric W. Schmidt (ERAS support). To: Subject: ERAS LOR reminder: [Your Name], [Rotation]

To whom it may concern:

Another quick note on my ERAS letter. I am to submit by [date] and applications begin to be considered by programs on [September 23] so I hope to have all letters before that date.

Attach the Letter Request Form again (Letter ID [ID]). I can send either a short case summary or an updated CV that will make writing easier if needed.

If your plans have changed and it’s not working out now, I get it. Please advise me either way, for my planning.

Thank you,

AAMC ID [number] | [phone] | [Your Name]

The line that is most important in this article is “Please let me know either way”. It converts a silence into a polite question.

Weak vs Better: the exit line

Weak: “Oh, I really need this letter or I will not be finished with my application.”

Better: “If the time no longer fits, I totally get that, let me know either way so I can plan.”

The first one puts the responsibility of the outcome on you. The second makes them only responsible for a reply, which is an easier thing to give.

If your attending has not sent you a LOR after 2 emails, what should you do?

Two weeks have passed, and you still have no response. Email 2, tweet 2, no reply. Now, it’s the channel that changes, not the tone.

Do these in order:

  1. Rule out the boring explanations. Check spam. Check that you are sending to the correct address, hospital addresses are subject to change when people move. Be sure to keep the entry as “Confirmed for Upload” and to not accidentally make a second entry with a different Letter ID.
  2. Pass by the coordinator. The program coordinator, clerkship coordinator, or department assistant may be able to reach the attending. He was kind enough to write my letter, one line. When is a good time to catch them or can I send them something to help?
  3. Be there, if you’re in the area. Following clinic (or following rounds). Two minutes. Take a Letter Request Form to print.
  4. Call once. One voice mail, less than 30 seconds that says your name and ERAS letter.

Do turn on your backup writer on the day you determine the letter is in jeopardy. Not next week. Not after the 4th email.

The four letter limit on the number of LORs for each program only applies to the number of LORs you assign to each program, MyERAS allows you to create as many LORs as you wish on the back. There is no cost to enter an additional entry. You are asking someone to take the time to write a thoughtful letter in 48 hours and that costs you something.

If the letter is uploaded but there is a problem,

Once the letter is uploaded, it is not possible to edit it. The AAMC’s Letter Writer Portal user guide states that if your writer uploaded the wrong file or used the wrong Letter ID, then they must upload a new version through the portal.

Another AAMC rule: After you have applied to a program, you cannot alter your letter choices for this program. The author may edit or remove his/her letter but it is not possible to replace it with another letter. Be careful with the assignments, and never bulk assign a letter on the day it arrives.

LOR Follow-Up Tips for International Medical Graduates 

Follow up is extra complicated for IMGs. Here are each one, and how to deal with them.

  1. Typically, your US letters are from short USCE rotations. After 4 weeks, you’re out of here. If rotating, ask before rotation ends, in person and agree the date of rotation before leaving the building. A conversation in the hallway is better than an email from another continent.
  2. No one is running out to get you. US seniors have a student affairs office that is dependent upon faculty. You have a spreadsheet you can use. While ECFMG serves as your dean’s office for other documents, ECFMG confirms that LORs for IMGs are submitted through the AAMC Letter Writer Portal only and do not contact writers on your behalf.
  3. It’s not a processing time issue. According to the document submission guidance by ECFMG, letters uploaded via the Letter Writer Portal will be available at the time of their upload and assignment. If your AAMC portal status is not “Uploaded”, the letter was not uploaded. Do not waste a week with it’s probably processing.
  4. Home country professors require a how to, rather than just a reminder. A professor in Lahore or in Lagos may have never seen the portal. Include an additional paragraph in your LOR reminder email: LOR writers can submit via the secure link in the AAMC email, without creating an account. The letter is to be uploaded as a PDF, which can be no larger than 1 MB, the account in the AAMC is optional. Provide 10 minute video call to review together.
  5. Designees uploading is ok. The professor’s secretary uploading is OK, the uploader is the secretary’s name. Program Directors know how to handle it. It doesn’t matter what if it’s a signed letter on institutional letterhead.
  6. Use the personal number carefully. In 2026, a single, brief WhatsApp message from an attending is an acceptable way of getting an attending’s mobile number, if it was provided during the rotation. No voice notes. No emojis. No second message.

On the other hand, programs with a tight focus on reading IMG files will catch letters which are specific and updated. A letter from a US attending who saw you present on rounds in September and saw that you chased down is more valuable than two letters sent on time. To select those writers, refer to our guide of how to select US letter writers (IMG).

The letter arrives. If the interview is done right, then everything should go well.

Your responses determine what happens inside the room, a strong letter opens the door. Our residency interview preparation involves letting an IMG who matched sit on the other end of the table, ask you questions you’ll be asked and ask questions you will need to ask the program director.

A strong letter opens the door. The interview wins the match.

Practice with an IMG who matched — real program-director questions, and the questions you should be asking back.

Prep My Interview →

Common LOR Follow-Up Mistakes to Avoid 

  • Submitting the same Letter Request Form to two writers. The second uploading is for one single letter, and ends up in the wrong entry.
  • Running after a letter that you did not promise. If no Letter ID exists then it is marked as “Not Confirmed for Upload”. You’re my writer, and I can’t upload.
  • Checking up on the following day. Minimum three business days after the target date.
  • Guilt language. “No response”, “I am getting worried”, “my application is incomplete in this manner”. All of these make the subsequent email less openable.
  • Vague subject lines. The “quick question” is put to the side. The “ERAS LOR” [Name, target [date]] is opened.
  • Forgetting to assign. It is possible to upload letters that will remain unassigned until you use them. Program directors are only ever assigned letters.
  • Assigning multiple tasks a single day, at the start of the course. No changes to letter swaps for programs already applied. For programs which explicitly request a lukewarm sound, keep that letter.
  • Skipping the thank you. If it is a letter that has been uploaded on a two line note the day of the upload. These people will be found at conferences, and you will seek some of them out for fellowship letters.

When you only have 10 minutes: The 5 moves

  1. Open MyERAS and take a screen shot of all the letter entries.
  2. Any items that are not “Not Confirmed for Upload”: confirm them and send the Letter Request Form today.
  3. Send the second follow up template above for any that are “Confirmed for Upload” or 3+ business days past its target date:
  4. If there are 2 unanswered emails: message the coordinator and send the email to a backup writer. Same day.
  5. If you get anything “Uploaded”   assign it and thank them.

One caution. Don’t run this list on autopilot and fire the same message at five people. Read each thread first. If an attending has answered “next week” on Monday, then there is no need for a second question on Wednesday.

Do this one thing if you can only do one thing here: send the second follow up to the one letter you’ve been procrastinating on. This is the one that is at risk.

Do you feel like the proper LOR Follow Up Tracker (Use It Tonight)?

Make sure this is stored in a spreadsheet or in your notes app on your phone, one line for each writer. Build time is 10 minutes, save a letter per cycle.

WriterSpecialty entryLetter IDStatusTarget dateLast contactNext action and dateBackup?
Dr. A (IM attending, USCE)Internal Medicine1234567Confirmed for UploadAug 20Aug 24, email (2nd)Aug 31: coordinator + one callDr. D asked Aug 24
Professor B (home school)General2345678Thank you email sent Aug 15Aug 20Aug 15Assign to programsNot needed
Dr. C (research mentor)Internal MedicineNone yetNot ConfirmedSept 1Aug 10, verbal yesConfirm entry + send form todayAug 25, decided

The letter you will lose will be the one in the “Next action” column at the bottom if it is blank.

Weak vs Better: use of the tracker

Weak: “I will remember to visit Dr. A next week.”

Better: “Dr. A: 2nd email Aug 24, call once if no reply by Aug 31.”

You will forget it. Everyone forgets during interview season, that’s why the date goes in the cell and not in your head. Use this tracker in conjunction with our ERAS 2027 checklist for IMGs and your entire residency application is in one place.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: How to follow up on a letter of recommendation for a residency?

Two to three weeks prior to the date you agreed upon, and three business days after the date. If you haven’t made a date, send one friendly email now proposing one. Wait two weeks and then change channels and lines up another writer if no response is received on two emails. Before that and you are reading with anxiety, after that, you lose your time.

Q2: How many follow up calls can I make to an attending about my LOR?

The typical limit is three contacts over a period of about a month (two emails, a coordinator, a phone call or a visit). Otherwise, it’s not typically memory. The contacts must be more brief and more succinct than the previous ones. Once the third, it’s a backup writer’s energy.

Q3: Would it be rude to remind an attending of a letter of recommendation?

No. Follow up is the responsibility of the AAMC and most attendings require one reminder. Tone, not frequency, is rude, guilty language, ambiguous messages, or an email the day after the promised date. The Letter Request Form attached is given as a courtesy.

Q4: When I check the letter, it is reported as uploaded in my attending, but not appearing in MyERAS. What now?

Before looking for the address in the General section, look for it in the Personal section of your email address, as the AAMC will notify about uploads there. Ask the writer to verify the Letter ID they used. The “processing” time is not the reason for the delay, since letters uploaded via the AAMC Letter Writer Portal will be visible immediately. If the ID is incorrect, they will need to upload again with the correct ID, if the ID is correct and nothing appears then contact the AAMC Support Center.

Q5: If my letter writer sends after I submit my ERAS application can they also send?

Yes. Letters can be uploaded and assigned throughout the season, to any program that has fewer than four letters assigned. Unfortunately, programs do not guarantee to look at the letters that come after your initial application, as the AAMC’s terms and conditions read. Late beats never. Before you send your letters, assign them to programs so they can access them as soon as they are reviewed, but don’t count on any letter being read.

Chase the Date Not the Person: Final Takeaway

A letter of recommendation is a favor you’re being asked to give. If you have a follow up, it’s your job, and it is. Set a date at the ask, remind in 2 to 3 weeks, remind again 3 business days before and change channel after 2 silences. Make each message short, include the form in each message and always request a response either way.

Applicants who don’t receive letters are not the ones who followed up too extensively. It’s they who waited for the portal to shift on its own.

Your attending didn’t bring your letter with him/her. Don’t forget your attendance in your mailbox.

To get a second opinion on your letter plan, your writers and the rest of your file before the Medical Residency Match, check out our IMG roadmap to the US residency match.

Don’t let a silent attending cost you a letter

The letter is the one part of your application you can’t control, but you can control the follow-up. IMG Helping Hands gets your letters in on time and the rest of your file ready before certification:

  • ✓ Letter strategy session — match your rotations, research and home-country mentors to the 3–4 letters each specialty wants
  • ✓ Individual ask emails — written around your submission date and each program’s open date
  • ✓ Step-by-step upload guide — to share with writers new to the AAMC Letter Writer Portal
  • ✓ Backup writer planning — so a silent attending never leaves you one letter short
  • ✓ Full application review — CV, personal statement, program list and letter assignments before you certify

Disclaimer

Articles published by IMG Helping Hands are prepared by our team using information from direct experience, publicly available resources, and educational references. AI tools may be used to assist with drafting, proofreading, and formatting; however, all content undergoes review and approval before publication. The information provided is intended for educational purposes only. Requirements, policies, and processes may change over time. Readers should consult official sources for the most current information.

Want to keep up with our blog?

Get our most valuable tips right inside your inbox, once per month!

0
No products in the cart.